200 Word RPG Challenge

Too many Sherlocks

A comedy game for 3+ know-it-alls.

You will need: pens, one piece of paper, and a willingness to attempt British accents. 

Designate one person to be Watson. Everyone else is Sherlock. Each player takes turns drawing part of a top-down crime-scene sketch (a broken vase, a corpse, etc), starting with Watson. When it’s Watson’s turn again, they describe the crime scene to everyone as if they’ve just walked in.  

Then the next player (Sherlock) must pick 1-2 objects on the paper and use them to make a dramatic deduction about how the crime happened.

Then the next Sherlock must do the same, except they start their explanation with a confident declaration that the last Sherlock has missed a vital clue.

Each person takes a turn as Sherlock until it returns to Watson. We recommend miming smoking a pipe when it’s your turn.

When it returns to Watson, they must say “by God, Holmes, you’ve solved it!” Then explain how the crime played out, using all the deductions the previous Sherlocks have supplied. 

The next Sherlock becomes Watson, a new paper is retrieved, and the game repeats.

The game continues as such until everyone has been Watson, or a fist-fight ensues.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *